The Poetry of William Wenthe
Distinguished Entry 2007
If I’m Reading You Right, Immanuel
Mid-spring, mid-afternoon, flecked shadows of half-fledged trees . . .
Compared to the book I’m struggling
to follow, how easy to surrender
to waxwings: their high-pitched corrugated whistlings
on the air, in it, as if the light had voice,
as if the chartreuse, scalloped unfurlings
of new walnut leaves were talking.
As if. The words distort, even as they tell me
what I see and hear. They lack the philosopher’s discipline,
that well-regulated man of Konigsberg, at his routine:
awake at five, in his nightgown at his desk,
a few coals on the raked fire for a trickle of heat,
as he writes, observing the pattern of his thoughts,
fine as the fractal frost on the panes that,
darkened, await the northern, late, winter dawn.
His days so orderly (it’s said the housewives set their clocks
by his afternoon walks) that only thoughts and weather
seemed to change. A vantage, almost, pure.
Or so I might think, though my own thinking
mystifies his sentences—
the way an inside radiator’s sighs
will fog to milkiness winter’s precision of light.
And the waxwings, all the while,
sounding their single note. They fly
from holly to maple in straight lines—
like something I’ve just read: that to draw a line in thought
is to apprehend one thing after another; which means
one moment must, he says, necessarily, he says, depend
upon my holding of the moment before.
He called this thought an a priori: philosophy’s reply
to In the beginning, whence all arises:
this phasing, this phrasing: the waxwings
singing themselves into becoming, riding on
their past. All this implication, this enabling—
the chiasmus of when and now.
Now then, by extension, as I sit in this garden,
am I not—necessarily—walking a sidewalk in Manhattan,
somewhere in Chelsea, near the comedy club
called Catch a Rising Star? It’s audition night
and my girlfriend, who’s nervous and prefers
an audience of strangers, will be on stage
for the first time, and I am forbidden to attend.
Two ways to please her, I’m thinking, two ways
to fail: one is to go in, one to stay away.
I contemplate disguises . . .
So then, now, if I’m reading it right,
that evening’s walk is somehow requisite
to this moment in the garden: crossed
in the crossed limbs and shadows; hanging
in cap and dark glasses in the back,
in the crowd-fringe, the under-hedge
where jonquils hang their hooded heads.
Now, I say, and the word’s round vowel calls
all my past. Still, there remains the problem
of all that’s forgotten . . . the weather of
that evening (I think it was spring),
what the signboard in the club window said,
the faces of other walkers, closed to me now
as the storefronts’ rolled-down metal doors.
And now, she and I are married
to other persons. There’s a truth the philosopher
of Reason and Judgment never faced, who kept himself
away from Eros, and in this, too, was wise,
guessing that love leads us to disguise
the outer world with our inmost selves.
How, when I come to love it, the wheezy note
of the waxwing seems like a word:
“here, here, here, here,” because here
is what I want to hear. Or when my wife
makes up our bed, and she kneels on the mattress
and draws the sheets and blankets toward her—
I think of the way a bird
finishes its nest, from the inside.
If I’m reading you right, Immanuel, it’s clear
we can reason past illusions toward a wordless pure,
though I fancy, too, the tumble of my days
disappearing into one another, and love
that dresses and undresses them in words.
Words like waxwings. For Daedalus, they really worked:
rising, he saw the labyrinth below,
even as he’d drawn it in his thought.
But for Icarus, they are only like wings,
elaborate similes of what he craves . . .
I picture him, with a smile, flying,
just before he falls.
“The way a bird . . . ,” I like to tell her
by way of chattering, exchanging words
that may be meaningless, but are enough to know
we’re here to hear each other speak.
Like waxwings’ whistlings, to tell us where we are.